Litigation SentinelSubscribe free
The weekly brief for F500 legal and claims leaders. Free.
AI on TrialAI on Trial

Plaintiff’s Two Firms Ordered to Pay State Farm $31,100 Over AI Brief

A Delaware court fined the lawyer who signed an error-filled brief but released his firm after examining controls it had put in place before filing. Two other orders show what happens when a draft crosses between lawyers without verified citations or a disclosed AI origin.

Wesley Todd, CEO, CaseGlideNovember 20, 20267 min read · 853 readers this week

Delaware law firm Richards, Layton & Finger escaped sanction on a written AI policy and training of over 200 employees; the partner who signed an AI-tainted brief owes $2,500 personally. Vice Chancellor Lori W. Will of the Delaware Court of Chancery found the partner had filed without verifying the authorities himself, initially shifted blame to a paralegal, and left inaccurate descriptions of the law in place after removing the quotation marks. Will’s November 13 letter opinion in Leiske v. Kidd released the firm from the joint responsibility the court’s sanctions rule presumes and ordered the partner to pay the court within 14 days and file an affidavit confirming payment. For a company that hires outside counsel, the ruling shows a court putting the whole penalty on the lawyer who signed and releasing a firm whose AI controls predated the filing. The inquiry described in earlier coverage is closed; the payment and affidavit are still due.

The bad citations were in a brief opposing the defendants’ challenge to a report on advancement. The defendants identified fabricated quotations, inaccurate citations and invented legal propositions in their reply. Plaintiffs’ lead counsel acknowledged using generative AI and filed a correction, but Will found that the revised brief still misdescribed the underlying decisions. Will’s opinion put the error and the attempted repair under the same inquiry: “It is not enough to remove quotation marks and leave a fabricated legal synthesis in place.”

The case file

Get the case file behind this story

The 3 sources behind this story: 3 court records, each linked with what it shows. Free with the weekly Litigation Sentinel brief.

  • court recordDelaware Court of Chancery, Leiske v. Kidd, C.A. No. 2025-0426-CDW (LWW), letter opinio...
  • court recordU.S. District Court for the District of Delaware, Gill v. Everyday Dose, C.A. No. 24-13...
  • and 1 more source
Join 1,847 litigation leaders who read it weekly.

The signature and the firm

Under the Court of Chancery’s Rule 11, “[a]bsent exceptional circumstances, a law firm must be held jointly responsible for violations committed by its partners, associates, or employees.” Will cited Delaware Lawyers’ Rule of Professional Conduct 5.1(a), concerning management’s efforts to ensure lawyers comply with professional obligations, and ABA Formal Opinion 512, concerning policies and supervision for generative AI, as “useful guidance” for deciding whether this firm met the exception.

Will drew a different line around the lawyer who signed: “An attorney’s signature on a court filing is not a procedural formality; it is a certification to the tribunal.” The opinion says the partner, who chaired the firm’s AI subcommittee, used a tool that had not been approved for general firm use while preparing arguments, delegated citation checking to a junior lawyer and a paralegal, and filed without personally verifying the authorities, citations and quotations after their review. Will credited his later acceptance of full responsibility and his contrition when setting the penalty. The order still required him to pay it himself because Rule 11’s verification requirement was nondelegable.

**P&L translation, Sentinel analysis:** For a GC hiring local counsel and co-counsel, these orders turn on three facts: who signs the filing, who checks the authorities in a draft passed between lawyers, and whether the firm’s AI policy predates the filing. In Leiske, the signer owes the court $2,500 while the firm owes no sanction. In the California order discussed below, a special master struck a plaintiff’s briefs, denied the discovery relief it sought, and ordered its two firms to pay $31,100. The Delaware firm’s release rested on dates it could prove: March 2023, July 2025 and January 2026.

What the judges weighed

Richards, Layton & Finger had barred unapproved generative AI tools in March 2023. Its board adopted a written policy in July 2025 requiring an experienced lawyer to review AI output for accuracy and completeness and barring its use as a substitute for independent legal judgment. More than 200 employees had completed the firm’s related training by January 2026, before the offending brief was filed. Will found that those measures demonstrated exceptional circumstances and that the firm “should not be sanctioned for an individual lawyer bypassing those controls.” The opinion summed it up: “In short, RLF did the right thing.” The firm was released without sanction.

Four days earlier, Magistrate Judge Eleanor G. Tennyson’s order in Gill v. Everyday Dose reached a local-counsel handoff in the federal District of Delaware. Outside counsel drafted the brief; Delaware counsel signed and filed it, and it “contained fictitious cases and false statements of law as hallucinated by AI.” Tennyson held that the Delaware lawyer violated Rule 11 even though his conduct “was not knowing,” in the order’s words. The court declined to sanction him, citing his credible testimony, significant remorse and substantial experience practicing in Delaware without issue. It fined the other two lawyers $3,000 each, citing their “greater culpability and lack of remorse” after finding that each had deflected blame onto others.

The court acknowledged that outside counsel often gives Delaware counsel draft filings shortly before they are due. It still held that the Delaware lawyer’s “role as Delaware counsel in this case does not absolve him of his responsibilities under Rule 11 to ensure that legal filings are supported by existing law.” Remorse shaped the sanction only after the court found the violation. In Leiske, earlier firm controls answered a separate question: whether the firm shared its partner’s liability.

Stay Informed

Subscribe to Litigation Sentinel

Free weekly intelligence for executives responsible for litigation exposure: the named decision-makers, dollar exposure, operating consequence, and next development.

Join 1,847 litigation leaders who read it weekly.

The handoff became more costly in Lacey v. State Farm General Insurance Co., a 2025 special master order in the federal Central District of California. Special master Michael R. Wilner, a retired U.S. magistrate judge, found that an AI-generated outline containing faulty research passed from one firm to co-counsel without disclosure of its origin. The order said no attorney or staff member at either firm “apparently cite-checked or otherwise reviewed that research before filing the brief with the Special Master.” About nine of its 27 citations were wrong in some way, and at least two cited authorities did not exist. After Wilner flagged two citations, counsel removed them and submitted a revised brief that still contained other AI errors, “without adequate disclosure of the use of AI,” in the special master’s words.

Wilner found the lawyers’ conduct tantamount to bad faith. The order struck the plaintiff’s supplemental briefs on the privilege dispute, denied further discovery relief on that issue, and ordered the two firms to pay $31,100 jointly and severally. It found further sanctions against the individual attorneys unwarranted, calling the episode “a collective debacle.” It also said that sending the AI material to other lawyers “without disclosing its sketchy AI origins realistically put those professionals in harm’s way.”

Readers can follow AI sanctions findings in the state through the Sentinel’s Delaware AI sanctions view, alongside verdict pages for Delaware and California.

The open court deadline

Will also denied the defendants’ August 4 request to present billing records. She explained that because the court opened this Rule 11 inquiry on its own, an award of attorneys’ fees was unavailable under Rule 11, and she credited the sworn affidavits already filed. The financial order that remains is the partner’s personal $2,500 payment to the court. The partner who signed the brief has 14 days from the November 13 decision to pay, and he must then file an affidavit confirming payment.

What the courts required of the lawyers

The courts held signing lawyers responsible for the authorities in their filings, regardless of who drafted or checked them (Leiske v. Kidd, Delaware Court of Chancery, November 13, 2026; Gill v. Everyday Dose, District of Delaware, November 9, 2026).

The special master struck the plaintiff’s briefs and ordered its two law firms to pay $31,100 after an AI outline crossed between them without disclosure of its origin and went unchecked, and after a revised brief was filed “without adequate disclosure of the use of AI” (Lacey v. State Farm General Insurance Co., Central District of California, May 5, 2025).

The court credited a written AI policy, a ban on unapproved generative AI tools and training in place before the filing when it released the firm (Leiske v. Kidd, Delaware Court of Chancery, November 13, 2026).

Sentinel view: Engagement terms should identify who checks citations and who signs; firm-to-firm handoffs should identify AI-origin research; clients can ask panel firms when their written policy and training took effect.

Sources

Want to see where your team stands?

The readiness check has five questions about your reported litigation practices. Use the summary to choose an operating question to explore.

Take the 2-minute readiness check →
Stay Informed

Subscribe to Litigation Sentinel

Free weekly intelligence for executives responsible for litigation exposure: the named decision-makers, dollar exposure, operating consequence, and next development.

Join 1,847 litigation leaders who read it weekly.
Litigation Sentinel
Published by CaseGlide · Subscribe · Request an executive briefing
© 2026 CaseGlide, Inc. All rights reserved.