Litigation SentinelSubscribe free
The weekly brief for F500 legal and claims leaders. Free.
CoverageCase Watch

Farmers Sent a Widow $17,360.87, Not $350,000; Jury Awarded $11.3 Million, WOWT Reports

An agent’s text about a policyholder’s heart hospitalization became central to a dispute over what the insurer knew when it issued coverage. WOWT reports that a second jury awarded the policyholder’s widow $11.3 million in bad-faith damages on October 16.

Wesley Todd, CEO, CaseGlideNovember 13, 20265 min read · 1,225 readers this week

Life insurer Farmers voided Jose Gaytan’s $350,000 policy after his death and sent his widow a $17,360.87 premium refund, a Nebraska Court of Appeals memorandum records. Months before the policy issued, Gaytan’s wife texted insurance agent Michael Powers while Gaytan was hospitalized in August 2018. Powers replied, “[w]as it his heart,” and she answered, “Yes.” Powers later testified: “I should have said heartburn, but I said heart, but I meant heartburn.” WOWT reports that a second jury on October 16 said Farmers should pay the widow, Vaneza Ramos, an Omaha mother of 10, $11.3 million in bad-faith damages. For any insurer that voids a life policy after a death, the lesson sits in that appellate record: what the selling agent was told before the policy issued became a disputed fact that helped return the claims to the trial court.

Farmers’ position was that Gaytan had failed to disclose a heart attack and that the company would not have issued the policy had it known his full medical history, according to the appellate memorandum. Powers denied knowing material information about Gaytan’s medical history. The court record says Ramos did not cash the refund check.

The case file

Get the case file behind this story

The 3 sources behind this story: 2 court records and 1 other source, each linked with what it shows. Free with the weekly Litigation Sentinel brief.

  • court recordNebraska Court of Appeals, Ramos v. Farmers New World Life Insurance Company and Michae...
  • court recordNebraska Court of Appeals case page, Ramos v. Farmers Insurance, No. A-23-0912, argued...
  • and 1 more source
Join 1,847 litigation leaders who read it weekly.

The message Powers received

Gaytan went to an emergency room on August 5, 2018, with chest pain radiating into his neck, jaw and left arm, the appellate memorandum says. The memorandum says his medical records showed a heart attack and inpatient treatment. After Ramos answered yes to Powers’ question about Gaytan’s heart, he replied, “I will pray.”

That exchange preceded Gaytan’s application for a Farmers policy. On October 24, 2018, Powers and Gaytan completed a questionnaire that asked about heart attacks and other heart conditions. Gaytan answered no. A second medical questionnaire, completed with an examiner on November 7, recorded a yes to a broader question about treatment or medication for heart conditions. Gaytan specified high cholesterol diagnosed that August and a prescription for lisinopril. Farmers issued the $350,000 policy on November 28.

Powers testified that he had asked about Gaytan’s heart because Gaytan had previously mentioned heartburn. WOWT characterized the text chain as showing that Powers knew Gaytan was hospitalized for his heart; the appellate court treated what Powers knew about the heart attack as a disputed factual question.

Gaytan died on May 31, 2020; his death certificate lists COVID-19 as the cause, according to the court record. WOWT reports that his death came 20 days after Ramos gave birth to their last baby. In June 2020, she sought payment as the policy’s sole beneficiary, the court record says.

A refund check instead of the policy

Stay Informed

Subscribe to Litigation Sentinel

Free weekly intelligence for executives responsible for litigation exposure: the named decision-makers, dollar exposure, operating consequence, and next development.

Join 1,847 litigation leaders who read it weekly.

Because Gaytan died within two years of the policy’s issue date, Farmers reviewed his application and medical records, the appellate memorandum says. In September 2020, it told Ramos that disclosure of his heart attack would have prevented issuance of the policy. Farmers treated the coverage as void from its start, denied her claim and sent the $17,360.87 check to return the premiums.

Ramos’ 2022 complaint, as the appellate memorandum describes it, alleged breach of contract and bad faith against Farmers and negligence against Powers. She argued that Powers’ knowledge gave Farmers notice before it issued the policy. Farmers argued that Gaytan’s material misrepresentation entitled it to rescind the contract, so denying the claim was neither a breach of contract nor bad faith.

The Douglas County District Court’s judgment, summarized on the Court of Appeals case page, initially ended all three claims in Farmers’ and Powers’ favor without a trial. Because Ramos had filed no statement of disputed facts, Judge Katie L. Benson treated Farmers’ and Powers’ statements of facts as undisputed; addressing the merits as well, she found that Powers, and so Farmers, was only aware that Gaytan was hospitalized for “heart problems.” Ramos appealed.

In December 2024, the Nebraska Court of Appeals reversed the judgment on the contract and bad-faith claims against Farmers. It held that the record left open whether Gaytan intended to deceive the insurer and whether Powers’ knowledge could be attributed to Farmers. The court affirmed summary judgment for Powers on the negligence claim. It reasoned that disclosure of Gaytan’s heart attack on either questionnaire would have prevented Farmers from issuing the policy. The memorandum was not designated for permanent publication; it records this case’s earlier appeal.

Two juries, two questions

The appellate decision returned the claims against Farmers to the trial court. WOWT reports that a first jury in March found Farmers breached the insurance contract, rejecting the allegation of fraudulent misrepresentation, and that a second jury on October 16 said Farmers should pay $11.3 million in bad-faith damages.

Farmers had issued a $350,000 policy, then sent a $17,360.87 return of premiums when it denied the claim. By our arithmetic, the $11.3 million bad-faith award WOWT reports is about 32 times the policy amount. Ramos’ lawyer said in WOWT’s report that the jury considered emotional distress and financial hardship. WOWT reported that the family’s truck was repossessed and that the family borrowed money while continuing its frozen dessert and diner businesses.

WOWT reported that Farmers’ legal team did not respond to a request for comment or say whether it would appeal. The December 2024 appellate memorandum says Ramos did not cash the $17,360.87 refund check. The Nebraska verdict WOWT reports since then is $11.3 million.

Sources

Want to see where your team stands?

The readiness check has five questions about your reported litigation practices. Use the summary to choose an operating question to explore.

Take the 2-minute readiness check →
Stay Informed

Subscribe to Litigation Sentinel

Free weekly intelligence for executives responsible for litigation exposure: the named decision-makers, dollar exposure, operating consequence, and next development.

Join 1,847 litigation leaders who read it weekly.
Litigation Sentinel
Published by CaseGlide · Subscribe · Request an executive briefing
© 2026 CaseGlide, Inc. All rights reserved.