Francis Melaragni, a former OneBeacon Insurance and Bottomline Technologies manager, wrote in January that defense lawyers now craft invoices 'designed to survive algorithmic scrutiny.' Defense lawyers have said much the same on the record, and claims chiefs now rank billing compliance fifth among their friction points with law firms.
Francis Melaragni spent more than a decade helping build legal bill review, the invoice audits insurers run on a litigation bill he put, citing AM Best, at an estimated $24 billion for 2023. In January he wrote that the savings "often prove illusory," and that defense lawyers now spend "meaningful time crafting invoice narratives designed to survive algorithmic scrutiny." The essay ran in Claims Journal on January 16, 2026, and in its sister publication for insurer executives on January 27. By his arithmetic, review vendors charge "roughly 1% to 2% of managed spend," a $240 million to $480 million annual market, for savings "reported to be in the range of 5% to 15%."
Melaragni is now a professor and program director of the pharmaceutical business program at MCPHS University. His author biography says he held senior management roles at Hewlett-Packard, OneBeacon Insurance and Allegient Systems/Bottomline Technologies. "For over a decade, I helped build the legal e-billing and review industry," he wrote. He spent those years across the table from claims vice presidents, "making the case that systematic invoice auditing was a fiduciary imperative."
Then he studied Lean, the Toyota Production System principles, and asked who the customer of bill review is. His answer was the policyholder: the business owner facing a slip-and-fall suit, the contractor named in a construction defect claim. "I helped build the current system because I believed it served policyholders," he wrote. "I now believe we need to revisit that assumption."
Free weekly intelligence for executives responsible for litigation exposure: the named decision-makers, dollar exposure, operating consequence, and next development.
He walked through a defense the way a policyholder would see it. When a bill is cut or rejected, the lawyer may appeal, "spending more hours on administrative process." The adjuster spends part of the week on billing details instead of moving the claim to resolution. Lean holds that any activity the customer would not willingly pay for is waste. He doubted an insured would pay for an appeal over a $47 reduction, or for hours of argument over whether 0.2 hours of email review was reasonable.
He listed what the reported savings leave out: "administrative costs, appeals, relationship damage and adjuster time diverted from the insured's actual claim."
His fix keeps review and changes how it is done. He proposed statistical sampling in place of line-item scrutiny of every invoice, and "calibration and training, not punitive reductions" when a sample finds a problem. He would measure firms on "time to resolution, defense effectiveness and total cost of resolution," and let firms that "consistently deliver strong outcomes for insureds earn autonomy." For the buyer who fears what happens without audits, he wrote one line: "If your default assumption is that defense partners will exploit your insureds unless watched constantly, you have a panel management problem."
Defense firms are now choosing their clients. A CLM survey of defense firms, unveiled in October 2025, found that more than 60% had turned down work for lack of capacity, "a practice unheard of until recently." Participating firms named "rates, audits, and lawyer satisfaction" as "primary factors in client selection." In CLM's 2026 Litigation Management Study, 38.7% of claims organizations said at least one panel firm had asked in the past six months to pause or halt new assignments because of staffing.
Defense lawyers have said much the same as Melaragni on the record. In the 2024 CLM Defense Counsel Study, run by the survey firm Suite 200 Solutions for the Claims and Litigation Management Alliance, insurance defense attorneys reported an average post-appeal invoice adjustment of 9.5%, CLM Magazine reported. Seventy-eight percent called the adjustments subjective or inconsistent, and the share calling them objective fell from 18% in 2020 to 8%.
At the CLM conference where the study was presented, J. Thaddeus Eckenrode, managing principal of Eckenrode-Maupin and the panel's outside counsel, said he would follow the billing guidelines he was given. His complaint was the auditor: "I don't understand how a guy two timezones away can look at my bill and say, 'This was excessive time for the work performed.'"
A Best's Review poll of defense counsel, reported by Insurance Business in May 2024, found 96% of respondents dissatisfied with insurers' financial constraints. Phil R. Richards, a partner at Richards & Connor, said the deterioration started when the industry began "referring to panel counsel as vendors rather than their lawyers." Mark Perkins of Perkins & Associates described audits that sometimes cut bills 5% to 10% arbitrarily. Those accounts come from lawyers describing their own pay.
Free weekly intelligence for executives responsible for litigation exposure: the named decision-makers, dollar exposure, operating consequence, and next development.
Over the same decade, liability insurers spent a smaller share on defense. Insurance Business, analyzing its own industry dashboard, reported that liability insurers devoted just over 20% of losses to defense costs in 2014 and 15.2% in 2024, while liability loss ratios climbed nearly 11 points to 60.6%. The publication drew no cause from the two lines, which show only a correlation; it wrote that "fewer legal dollars may not be slowing the tide of costly claims."
The answers claims executives give have shifted. In CLM's 2026 study of more than 70 chief claim and litigation officers, 80.6% said average indemnity on settled litigated files had risen over three years, Insurance Journal reported. Asked whether spending more on defense reduces indemnity, 63.9% said no, down from 81% in 2023. Taylor Smith, president of Suite 200 Solutions, said the top friction point with law firms is now the need for "more accurate exposure analysis from law firms." Billing compliance, long first, had fallen to fifth.
Sentinel found no published study testing whether a better defense lawyer lowers what a civil case pays out. Few buyers keep the score that would settle it, and corporate legal departments show the same gap. In a survey of 284 chief legal officers, general counsel and legal operations professionals worldwide by Everlaw and the Association of Corporate Counsel, released in November 2025, 83% tracked outside counsel spend, 16% tracked litigation outcomes relative to cost and 12% tracked outside counsel performance. CLM's 2026 study found that 94.9% of claims executives use no outcome-based pay with their firms, CLM Magazine reported.
Sentinel analysis. Legal fees are the smaller part of what a lawsuit costs. In liability lines, defense ran about 15 cents for each dollar of losses in 2024 by Insurance Business's count. At the 2024 CLM conference, Smith described "indemnity issues that comprise 80% of total case costs." The settlement or the verdict is the larger number.
An invoice records hours, rates, task codes and the timekeeper. It carries no demand, no offer, no settlement amount, no count of months to resolution and no record of how one lawyer's cases end in one venue. Those numbers sit in the claim file, and many claims organizations keep them unevenly. CLM's 2026 study found that 82% do not track who on the defense team extends a settlement offer, and 56.7% do not track the number of policy limit demands made against them.
A buyer who sees only invoices can rank lawyers on price and on billing compliance. That buyer cannot rank them on what their cases cost when they close, the measure Melaragni wrote should earn a firm its autonomy. A firm with the higher rate that settles sooner, and below the last demand, can be the cheaper hire. The invoice records only the higher rate.
CaseGlide, which owns Litigation Sentinel, reviews legal bills through its Legal Spend Management, and its Litigation Intelligence dashboards put the case data beside those bills. A company using both can see what each firm billed next to how its cases resolved, negotiation and settlement history included.
Melaragni closed his essay on the policyholder: "When the insured is the center of gravity, the right answers about cost, quality and process will follow." The man who once made the case for auditing every invoice ended by asking for a different measure, the result the insured gets. This year, for the first time in 11 years of studies, more than 1 in 3 claims executives in CLM's study believe that spending more on the defense of a lawsuit reduces its indemnity costs. The same study asked whether their organizations record who on the defense team extends a settlement offer. Eighty-two percent do not.
Each week, one sourced story about how companies and insurers buy legal defense, and what the invoices leave out.
Bring your questions to a guided demo on sample matters.
The readiness check has five questions about your reported litigation practices. Use the summary to choose an operating question to explore.
Take the 2-minute readiness check →Free weekly intelligence for executives responsible for litigation exposure: the named decision-makers, dollar exposure, operating consequence, and next development.