Litigation SentinelSubscribe free
The weekly brief for F500 legal and claims leaders. Free.
Litigation StrategyCase Watch

Epstein Victim Challenges BNY Dismissal After Alleging at Least $600 Million in Suspicious Wires

Judge Jed S. Rakoff let trafficking claims against Bank of America proceed but dismissed the suit against BNY. With the appeal set for argument on November 18, the Second Circuit must decide whether the complaint connects the correspondent bank closely enough to Epstein’s operation.

Wesley Todd, CEO, CaseGlideNovember 20, 20265 min read · 1,219 readers this week
Painting of a woman on a moonlit shore watching a bridge of gold threads from a bank stop short of an island
Jane Doe alleges BNY processed at least $600 million in suspicious wires tied to Epstein; a judge dismissed her claims, and she is appealing. Illustration: Litigation Sentinel

A judge kept Bank of America in one Epstein victim’s trafficking suit but dismissed another’s against BNY, a correspondent bank accused of processing at least $600 million in suspicious wires. Jane Doe, the pseudonymous victim suing BNY, says in her appeal brief that Mellon United National Bank, then a BNY subsidiary, gave MC2 a credit line Epstein personally guaranteed; the brief calls MC2 the sham “modeling agency” that Epstein and Jean-Luc Brunel “used to recruit and traffic young women.” Her appeal was set for argument in the Second Circuit on November 18. At least $600 million is the alleged volume of suspicious wires, not a damages award; the live question is why claims against one bank survived while those against the other did not.

Judge Jed S. Rakoff of the Southern District of New York drew that line in his February 11 opinion. He held that a separate plaintiff’s complaint against Bank of America alleged special services and direct dealings, and let her participation and obstruction claims proceed. For BNY, he wrote, the complaint did not allege “any non-routine services” or that “any BNY employee played any role in structuring Epstein-related accounts or transfers or even communicated with Epstein.” BNY’s own appellate brief is sealed; the district court’s ruling states the position that prevailed for the bank.

The case file

Get the case file behind this story

The 3 sources behind this story: 3 court records, each linked with what it shows. Free with the weekly Litigation Sentinel brief.

  • court recordSecond Circuit, Jane Doe v. Bank of New York Mellon Corp., No. 26-703, plaintiff’s appe...
  • court recordSouthern District of New York, Doe v. Bank of America, N.A., No. 25-cv-8520 (JSR), and...
  • and 1 more source
Join 1,847 litigation leaders who read it weekly.

Two banks, two sets of allegations

Jane Doe brought a proposed class action under the TVPA, the federal anti-trafficking law that lets victims sue those who knowingly benefit from participating in a trafficking venture. Her complaint alleges that BNY “processed at least $600 million of suspicious wire transfers” and kept at least 12 accounts for Epstein and his known entities and agents between 2013 and 2019.

The opinion describes a different set of allegations against Bank of America. The Bank of America plaintiff alleged that the bank gave her preferential service, handled transfers through her account despite circumstances the complaint called suspicious, served entities linked to Epstein and intentionally delayed suspicious activity reports. Rakoff held that those allegations described more than ordinary banking. He let the participation claim continue. He also held that the complaint sufficiently alleged intentional obstruction after the investigation of Epstein became public.

For BNY, the judge saw a bank working largely through other financial institutions. The complaint alleged transfers involving women described as victims or otherwise connected to Epstein’s trafficking venture, but Rakoff found no allegations that BNY processed them unusually or knew the payments would support trafficking. He described the pleaded role as passive facilitation, short of the active engagement he required for a participation claim. That distinction, rather than the size of the wires alone, is the center of the appeal.

Stay Informed

Subscribe to Litigation Sentinel

Free weekly intelligence for executives responsible for litigation exposure: the named decision-makers, dollar exposure, operating consequence, and next development.

Join 1,847 litigation leaders who read it weekly.

The credit line Jane Doe wants counted

Jane Doe’s brief presses the court to look beyond the transfers. It dates the Mellon United credit line to around 2009. Jane Doe argues that this financing, together with the suspicious transactions and alleged failures to file timely reports, connected BNY to the venture.

Rakoff treated the credit line separately. He left open whether the subsidiary’s conduct could be attributed to BNY, then held that the complaint still failed to allege the credit was a non-routine service. Jane Doe’s appeal challenges both the treatment of that financing and the judge’s view of what a correspondent bank can do that amounts to participation. Her brief argues that correspondent status cannot itself shield a bank from liability. The opinion’s narrower answer is that this complaint did not allege the direct, unusual conduct it found in the Bank of America case.

The obstruction claims split too. Rakoff held that the Bank of America complaint alleged intentional delays in reporting suspicious activity, including after the 2019 investigation became public. He found the BNY complaint’s assertions of intentional obstruction conclusory. The BNY complaint itself alleged that the bank filed a report in August 2019 covering hundreds of transfers over more than six years, a fact the judge found inconsistent with the complaint’s theory of deliberate obstruction of the public investigation. Jane Doe argues on appeal that the judge read in a requirement that the bank know of a pending investigation, which she says the statute does not impose.

What the appeal can change

Rakoff’s January 29 order announced the split, and his February 11 opinion explained the reasons. Final judgment dismissing the BNY action with prejudice was entered on February 18, and Jane Doe filed her notice of appeal on March 20. The district court also dismissed the negligence claims under New York law as too late. Jane Doe asks the appeals court to restore those claims as well.

For legal and claims leaders, the exposure question in this record is whether alleged transaction volume, a former subsidiary’s credit line and reporting failures can connect a correspondent bank to Epstein’s alleged trafficking venture when the complaint identifies no unusual service or employee contact. **P&L translation:** a trafficking claim that survives a motion to dismiss keeps a bank in the case, as the two Bank of America claims did; a claim that fails at the pleading stage ends it, as every BNY claim did. **Leading indicator:** how the Second Circuit treats the MC2 credit line, which Rakoff said the complaint did not allege was a non-routine service. Under the February 11 ruling, two trafficking claims survived against Bank of America, while every claim against BNY was dismissed with prejudice. The Second Circuit’s decision, on the open docket, will determine whether Jane Doe can reopen that side of the case.

Sources

Want to see where your team stands?

The readiness check has five questions about your reported litigation practices. Use the summary to choose an operating question to explore.

Take the 2-minute readiness check →
Stay Informed

Subscribe to Litigation Sentinel

Free weekly intelligence for executives responsible for litigation exposure: the named decision-makers, dollar exposure, operating consequence, and next development.

Join 1,847 litigation leaders who read it weekly.
Litigation Sentinel
Published by CaseGlide · Subscribe · Request an executive briefing
© 2026 CaseGlide, Inc. All rights reserved.