Litigation SentinelSubscribe free
The weekly brief for F500 legal and claims leaders. Free.
Litigation StrategyCase Watch

Plaintiffs Say Meta Downgraded 93% of Re-Reviewed Documents, Seek Jury Instruction

Plaintiffs say Meta dropped or narrowed privilege claims on 93 percent of the documents it rechecked under court order. They want fees and a jury instruction on Meta’s alleged withholding; the parties stipulated to a December 14 hearing, subject to court approval.

Wesley Todd, CEO, CaseGlideNovember 20, 20264 min read · 1,144 readers this week

School district and personal injury plaintiffs want fees and a jury instruction on Meta’s alleged withholding in a federal social media proceeding with 4,309 actions pending as of November 2. In their November 13 sanctions motion, they say Meta, owner of Instagram and Facebook, dropped or narrowed privilege claims on 93 percent of the documents it rechecked in a court-ordered review, including 56,747 of 60,462 in week two. The motion asks Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers of the Northern District of California to sanction Meta. It cites earlier trial testimony, as the motion characterizes it, that Meta researchers put privilege labels on sensitive material, including “anything that [Meta] wouldn’t want the public to see.” The parties stipulated to a December 14 hearing, subject to court approval; if the judge grants the instruction, a privilege dispute from discovery would reach the jury.

How the 93 percent figure arose

The actions sit in an MDL, thousands of cases gathered before one judge; the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation’s November 2 case list places them before Judge Gonzalez Rogers. The claims concern the effects of social media on young users.

The case file

Get the case file behind this story

The 3 sources behind this story: 3 court records, each linked with what it shows. Free with the weekly Litigation Sentinel brief.

  • court recordNorthern District of California, In re Social Media Adolescent Addiction/Personal Injur...
  • court recordJudicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation, Pending MDL Dockets by MDL Number, November...
  • and 1 more source
Join 1,847 litigation leaders who read it weekly.

The motion says Meta had withheld about 130,000 documents in full by the April 4, 2025 discovery cutoff. Plaintiffs then identified documents for priority review in an updated index. They say Meta withdrew or narrowed privilege claims on 727 of 926 documents in that group, or 79 percent. In the first weekly review ordered by the court, the motion reports 14,397 downgrades among 16,038 documents, or 90 percent; for the second week, it reports 56,747 among 60,462, or 94 percent. Plaintiffs put the cumulative rate at 93 percent as of their filing.

Those are plaintiffs’ figures, drawn from their motion. A downgrade means Meta released a document or reduced a redaction after revisiting a privilege claim. Plaintiffs argue the numbers “reveal systemic over-designation, not isolated error,” and that the scale warrants sanctions.

A document that arrived late

Stay Informed

Subscribe to Litigation Sentinel

Free weekly intelligence for executives responsible for litigation exposure: the named decision-makers, dollar exposure, operating consequence, and next development.

Join 1,847 litigation leaders who read it weekly.

The motion describes a 2016 slide deck, previously withheld in full, that concerns underage users and refers to Mark Zuckerberg and Sheryl Sandberg. The deck’s substantive passages are redacted in the public filing.

Plaintiffs say the timing has changed their trial preparation. They report receiving material from tens of thousands of documents for the first time less than three months before trial, after depositions and expert work had taken place. In their account, a newly released document can be difficult to use when the relevant witness was never questioned about it during discovery. The motion asks the judge to prevent Meta from objecting to use of the downgraded material on grounds such as authenticity, foundation or a witness’s personal knowledge, while preserving the judge’s ability to address unfair prejudice and other trial concerns.

The requested jury instruction goes further. Plaintiffs want jurors told that Meta improperly withheld discoverable material and that they may consider that conduct when weighing the evidence. Their proposed text would permit, but would not require, jurors to infer that Meta believed the documents were unfavorable to it. That text is plaintiffs’ proposal; the court decides whether jurors hear it.

The decision before Judge Gonzalez Rogers

Plaintiffs also seek reasonable fees and costs tied to the privilege dispute. They ask Judge Gonzalez Rogers to require court permission before Meta can withdraw a document released through the review on a renewed claim of privilege. The motion presents these requests as ways to address the lost opportunity to question witnesses and develop expert evidence while the documents were withheld.

**P&L translation:** The fee request is bounded by the cost of the privilege fight. The proposed instruction has no such ceiling: if granted, it would let jurors weigh Meta’s document handling alongside the documents themselves, and with 4,309 actions pending as of November 2, the result of any one trial can shape how the rest are valued. The motion says Meta's cumulative downgrade rate reached 93 percent during the court-ordered re-review and seeks sanctions.

The parties have stipulated to a hearing on **December 14, 2026, at 9 a.m. Pacific Time by Zoom** before Judge Gonzalez Rogers, subject to court approval. So far, the court has ordered the weekly re-reviews and plaintiffs have reported what came out of them; whether sanctions follow is the open question. The motion seeks four specific sanctions: rules for using the documents at trial, a jury instruction, limits on renewed privilege claims, and fees and costs. It also asks for other appropriate relief, including a focused evidentiary hearing if needed.

Sources

Want to see where your team stands?

The readiness check has five questions about your reported litigation practices. Use the summary to choose an operating question to explore.

Take the 2-minute readiness check →
Stay Informed

Subscribe to Litigation Sentinel

Free weekly intelligence for executives responsible for litigation exposure: the named decision-makers, dollar exposure, operating consequence, and next development.

Join 1,847 litigation leaders who read it weekly.
Litigation Sentinel
Published by CaseGlide · Subscribe · Request an executive briefing
© 2026 CaseGlide, Inc. All rights reserved.