Litigation SentinelSubscribe free
The weekly brief for F500 legal and claims leaders. Free.
Litigation StrategyCase Watch

J-M Manufacturing’s Racketeering Claims Survive Against Firm It Says Recovered More Than $10.7 Billion

An Illinois federal judge allowed three racketeering counts to proceed on J-M Manufacturing’s allegations of false testimony and hidden bankruptcy evidence in asbestos cases, allegations taken as true only at the pleading stage. He dismissed three state claims without prejudice and denied a separate request to strike them under California law.

Wesley Todd, CEO, CaseGlideNovember 20, 20264 min read · 1,842 readers this week

J-M Manufacturing Company, Inc., an industrial pipe maker that says it has been sued in more than 6,000 asbestos cases, kept two federal racketeering counts alive against the law firm Simmons Hanly Conroy, LLP, and a third against individual defendants. In his November 6 order, Judge Robert W. Gettleman of the federal court in Illinois dismissed J-M’s three California-law claims without prejudice and denied the defendants’ request to strike them under California’s anti-SLAPP law; surviving dismissal proves nothing, because every fraud fact is J-M’s allegation, taken as true only to test the pleading. The complaint alleges that the firm scripted product identification testimony and concealed bankruptcy evidence, allegations that, as the order describes them, surfaced in a former partner’s lawsuit. It also says the firm represented more than 8,000 asbestos claimants and recovered more than $10.7 billion in asbestos litigation. The defendants must answer the surviving counts by December 7; a joint status report is due December 14.

The defendants had asked Gettleman to dismiss the entire amended complaint. They argued that ordinary litigation activity cannot serve as an act of racketeering and that settled cases, voluntary dismissals and a verdict for one of their clients undercut J-M’s account. Gettleman opened the order this way: “Fed up with playing defense, plaintiff went on offense.” The order takes J-M’s allegations as true, as the law requires when a judge decides only whether a complaint can proceed.

Nuclear Verdicts dashboard

See the nuclear verdicts tracked in California

The California panel is open to everyone: the verdict count, total damages, median and largest verdict. Subscribe free to open every other state on the map, plus one courtroom story every Monday.

Join 1,847 litigation leaders who read it weekly.

More than 6,000 asbestos cases alleged against one pipe maker

J-M sold asbestos cement pipe from 1983 to 1988. The complaint says J-M has been sued in more than 6,000 asbestos cases since 2000 and that the defendant firm filed more than 430 of them.

J-M’s account, as the order describes it, starts from that former partner’s lawsuit. The company says a subsequent review of its cases found evidence of a recurring method: witnesses allegedly gave scripted accounts identifying J-M pipe, while evidence of exposure to products made by bankrupt companies was allegedly withheld. In one case described in the order, J-M alleges that a proof of claim filed in the CertainTeed/DBMP bankruptcy case on behalf of Perkins’ wife was concealed during the Perkins case against J-M, which J-M settled in 2023.

The P&L translation: J-M says it spent significant sums responding to allegations it calls false and paid settlements it calls unwarranted. Gettleman found J-M’s alleged pattern across several suits sufficiently pleaded to proceed at this stage.

Why the federal claims stayed alive

Stay Informed

Subscribe to Litigation Sentinel

Free weekly intelligence for executives responsible for litigation exposure: the named decision-makers, dollar exposure, operating consequence, and next development.

Join 1,847 litigation leaders who read it weekly.

This is the second version of J-M’s case. Gettleman dismissed J-M’s original complaint because that complaint had not adequately described a racketeering enterprise separate from the people accused of running it. J-M amended the pleading and added another law firm, Sokolove Law, LLC, as a defendant. The court held that the revised allegations adequately described two proposed enterprises and the defendants’ alleged roles in them at this stage.

The sharper dispute was over conduct inside lawsuits. The defendants argued that filing and prosecuting cases, even ones alleged to be baseless, could not become racketeering acts merely because pleadings or other papers traveled by mail or electronic communication. Gettleman rejected a categorical bar. He distinguished a single allegedly fraudulent lawsuit from J-M’s allegation of a pattern across several cases involving false testimony and concealed information.

The court allowed the federal racketeering and conspiracy counts, brought under the RICO statute, to proceed against the named defendants. The unnamed Doe defendants were dismissed without prejudice. J-M still has to prove that witnesses lied, that evidence was hidden and that settlements were unwarranted.

California law split the ruling

California law produced a different outcome for J-M’s three state claims, which alleged fraud, unjust enrichment and civil conspiracy. Gettleman held that California law governed those claims and that its litigation privilege barred them. He dismissed all three without prejudice.

The defendants also sought to strike those same claims under California’s anti-SLAPP law, a procedure aimed at claims arising from protected speech or petitioning. Gettleman denied that request, along with the motion’s demand for attorneys’ fees.

Scoreboard after the order: three federal RICO counts alive, three California-law claims out without prejudice, the anti-SLAPP motion denied. The Northern District of Illinois docket records one filing since: a November 19 request for extra pages. By December 7, the defendants must answer the three federal counts that survived; by December 14, both sides must report the case’s status to Gettleman. After more than 6,000 asbestos suits on defense, by its complaint’s count, J-M now gets to play offense in federal court.

Sources

Want to see where your team stands?

The readiness check has five questions about your reported litigation practices. Use the summary to choose an operating question to explore.

Take the 2-minute readiness check →
Stay Informed

Subscribe to Litigation Sentinel

Free weekly intelligence for executives responsible for litigation exposure: the named decision-makers, dollar exposure, operating consequence, and next development.

Join 1,847 litigation leaders who read it weekly.
Litigation Sentinel
Published by CaseGlide · Subscribe · Request an executive briefing
© 2026 CaseGlide, Inc. All rights reserved.