Old Dominion did not cause the crash, the parties agreed. Arkansas's Supreme Court, split 4 to 3, still reinstated $75 million in compensatory damages for six first responders after a jury found the company negligent for not telling emergency authorities about a barrel of formic acid. Old Dominion can ask the court for rehearing through November 23. That verdict came from state court. Below is where Old Dominion and seven other fleets get sued for injuries in federal court, with a blank row for your company.
Old Dominion Freight Line did not cause the crash, the parties agreed, yet six first responders won a $75 million compensatory verdict against the freight hauler. Arkansas's Supreme Court wrote that the company, which a trial expert described as the third largest trucking company in the United States, did not notify law enforcement that its overturned rig carried a barrel of formic acid until 8:51 p.m., "more than five hours after the accident." The court added that expert testimony established the men will live the rest of their days as if "breathing through a straw." On November 5 the Arkansas Supreme Court, split 4 to 3, reinstated the verdict. The state Court of Appeals had reversed in part, on damages, and ordered a new trial. Old Dominion has until November 23 to ask the court to reconsider; as of November 13 the court's public docket showed no such request.
On Highway 70 in St. Francis County, a pickup crossed the center line and hit the Old Dominion truck head-on. The parties stipulated that the pickup's driver, who was killed, was "the sole cause of the accident." The trailer carried no hazardous-materials placard, and federal law did not require one: the barrel weighed 565 pounds, and below 1,001 pounds the Hazardous Materials Transportation Act did not mandate a placard, the court wrote. The jury found something narrower: that Old Dominion, through its employees, "was negligent for not disclosing to the emergency-response authorities the presence of a hazardous material." It rejected punitive damages.
That narrow finding is why the case travels. The theory that held needed no crash caused by the trucking company and no broken placard rule. What it had was a small load under the federal line, someone else's wreck, and hours between a question at the scene and an answer from the company. On those facts the jury found negligent nondisclosure and found that it caused the men's injuries, and a four-justice majority upheld the award after reviewing each man's evidence of injury.
The 7 sources behind this story: 2 court records, 1 SEC filing, 2 government records, and 2 other sources, each linked with what it shows. Free with the weekly Litigation Sentinel brief.
With no placard on the trailer, the officers turned to the driver. Two officers who are not plaintiffs testified that they asked the driver whether he was hauling hazardous materials and that he said no. The driver and another witness denied that one of those officers asked. Both officers told dispatch that no hazardous materials were involved.
The six men arrived over the next hours: two law officers and four tow workers. The first of the six to arrive, a state trooper, noticed an odor after an hour and a half to two hours. He had not smelled it at other fiery crashes. At 7:49 p.m. he told dispatch they had all inhaled a foreign substance. A tow-company employee testified that when she called Old Dominion for the shipping papers, the company "blew [her] off." The majority called her testimony "cumulative of other evidence showing attempts to obtain the hazardous-materials information."
Writing for the majority, Justice Courtney Rae Hudson rejected three defenses a fleet would expect to hold. The majority held that federal hazmat law did not preempt, or override, the claim, because a duty to give responders the information was "substantively the same" as the federal duty to disclose "immediately upon request." It held that the professional-rescuer doctrine, which usually bars paid rescuers from suing over the dangers they are employed to confront, did not apply where the hazard went undisclosed. And it held that, for a one-time exposure, the plaintiffs did not need expert proof of "the necessary amount of exposure."
The dissent went after that last holding. The plaintiffs' pulmonologist had seen no scientific studies linking the men's injuries to formic acid and had treated no other patient exposed to it, the majority noted; he reviewed the acid's safety data sheets and drew on four decades of treating first responders. Justice Cody Hiland, writing for the dissent, called that testimony "a Google search with a medical degree."
The jury split the money man by man. It gave $25 million to the state trooper who was the first of the six to arrive and $20 million to the tow worker who brought his crew to the scene. It gave $15 million to a sheriff's corporal and $5 million each to three members of the tow crew.
Free weekly intelligence for executives responsible for litigation exposure: the named decision-makers, dollar exposure, operating consequence, and next development.
Justice Hiland, joined by Justices Wood and Bronni, counted $15,156 in medical expenses for the three men whose bills were admitted at trial. Each of those three was awarded $5 million. The other three men kept their bills out of evidence at trial, and the majority held that Old Dominion had not preserved that issue for appeal. Those three received $25 million, $20 million and $15 million. "The appellees had less than $15,200 in total medical expenses, yet they walked away with $75 million," the dissent wrote. It called the result "an institutionalized lottery."
The majority called that line of attack an "obsession." "Simply put, pain, suffering, and loss of enjoyment of life do not come with receipts," Justice Hudson wrote. In another footnote, Justice Hudson wrote that "Twelve Arkansans heard the evidence, assessed credibility, and valued the plaintiffs' injuries" and that this was "precisely the function our system assigns to them." As for weighing this award against other verdicts, the majority repeated that "precedents are of scant value in appeals of this kind."
Justice Barbara Webb did not participate. A footnote says Special Justice Cory Cox was appointed to replace Justice Webb. The opinion's vote line shows he joined the majority. That footnote also records that on October 8, Justice Rhonda Wood denied a motion to recuse filed by the first responders.
The trial ran December 7 to 15, 2021, before St. Francis County Circuit Judge E. Dion Wilson. On the sixth day the judge saw papers moving through the gallery. They were lunch menus, passed among shadow jurors: people employed by the plaintiffs' counsel to sit in on the trial. The opinion says the judge reprimanded counsel for not disclosing them, denied Old Dominion's motion for a mistrial and told the jury the recess concerned "external issues." The court also let the plaintiffs' lawyers make what the opinion calls "reptilian-style arguments," which frame liability in terms of community safety and danger. The judge barred Golden Rule arguments, which ask jurors to imagine themselves as a party. The jury returned $75 million in compensation and declined to award punitive damages.
In a December 22, 2021, motion, the company's trial lawyer called the ruling "shocking to the conscience," the trucking trade paper The Trucker reported. Describing its cargo, property damage, personal injury, workers' compensation and healthcare claims in general terms, the company's 2025 annual report, filed February 24, told shareholders that it assumes "a significant portion of the risk associated with these claims due to our self-insured retentions and deductibles." It listed as a risk that "claims prove to be more severe than our original assessment." Old Dominion's liability for claims and insurance stood at $168.8 million at the end of 2025.
This verdict came from an Arkansas state court. The table below counts federal suits only and does not price state-court verdict risk. For each company it gives a floor count of personal-injury suits filed in federal court in fiscal 2021 through 2025, from the Federal Judicial Center's Integrated Database of federal civil filings. Beside that count sit the share of those suits that began in state court and were removed to federal court, and the districts where they cluster. The last column is each company's size in trucks and tractors, as reported to the federal trucking safety regulator and read from FMCSA SAFER. Of Old Dominion's 35 counted federal injury suits, 60.0% began in state court. Suits that stayed in state court appear in no column.
| Company | Federal injury filings FY2021-FY2025 | Removed from state court | Motor vehicle (NOS 350/355) | Top federal districts | FMCSA power units |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ArcBest | 16 | 75.0% | 75.0% | New Jersey (4); Maryland (2) | 4,604 |
| FedEx | 241 | 69.3% | 74.7% | Georgia - Northern (18); Pennsylvania - Eastern (16); New York - Eastern (14) | 156,957 |
| J.B. Hunt | 109 | 73.4% | 83.5% | New York - Eastern (17); New York - Southern (17); Texas - Southern (7) | 25,280 |
| Knight-Swift | 94 | 73.4% | 87.2% | Texas - Western (13); Georgia - Northern (11); Texas - Northern (9) | 16,140 |
| Old Dominion | 35 | 60.0% | 77.1% | Texas - Western (3); Georgia - Middle (2); Illinois - Northern (2) | 10,313 |
| Saia | 18 | 72.2% | 77.8% | New Jersey (2); Texas - Northern (2); Texas - Southern (2) | 7,428 |
| UPS | 88 | 60.2% | 56.8% | Pennsylvania - Eastern (11); New York - Southern (6); New York - Eastern (5) | 112,321 |
| XPO | 26 | 76.9% | 69.2% | Arizona (3); Georgia - Northern (3); New Jersey (3) | 10,104 |
| Your company | ? | ? | ? | ? | ? |
Eight companies have a row. Which of them knows its own number?
At 7:49 p.m. on April 20, 2018, the first of the six to arrive told dispatch they had all inhaled a foreign substance. At 8:51 p.m., a state trooper received an email from Old Dominion. It carried a bill of lading and a safety data sheet, which said formic acid has "acute toxicity" when inhaled. Old Dominion has until November 23 to ask for rehearing, and the decision is not final while that window is open.
Litigation Sentinel's research desk builds this report with CaseGlide, the company behind Sentinel. Built from public court records. You send nothing and connect nothing.
Free weekly intelligence for executives responsible for litigation exposure: the named decision-makers, dollar exposure, operating consequence, and next development.