Litigation SentinelSubscribe free
The weekly brief for F500 legal and claims leaders. Free.
Trial DramaCase Watch

Walmart Wins New Trial After Shopper’s Lawyer Priced Pain Off Expert’s $8,000 Day

Georgia’s appeals court reversed the judgment entered on a $975,000 slip-and-fall verdict after the shopper’s lawyer compared her pain to a defense expert’s fee and the minimum wage. The court held that Georgia’s 2025 law bars those unrelated comparisons, while still allowing lawyers to suggest a value per hour or day.

Wesley Todd, CEO, CaseGlideNovember 13, 20265 min read · 1,576 readers this week

Walmart and Georgia shopper Ruby Medders fought over how her lawyer argued for a $1,136,000 award under a 2025 law barring pain comparisons to unrelated values. At closing, the shopper’s lawyer cast a defense expert’s $8,000 trial day as the equivalent of three million dollars a year and invoked minimum wage, comparisons the appeals court found “improper and harmful,” grounds for a new trial. On October 29, the Court of Appeals of Georgia reversed the judgment on the $975,000 verdict and remanded the case. The court said the uncorrected argument could have affected that award, which followed a claim for $186,000 in medical bills. Defense lawyers in Georgia injury trials now have a reversal to cite when a closing prices pain off an unrelated number. The fall’s effect on Medders’ knee and the value of her injuries remain at issue on remand.

An expert’s fee enters the closing argument

Medders sued after she slipped and fell during a November 2020 visit to a Valdosta Walmart store. She said the fall worsened knee pain and eventually required surgery. Walmart maintained that her knee condition existed before the fall and that the fall did not require her later surgeries. That disagreement went to a jury in January 2026.

Nuclear Verdicts dashboard

See the nuclear verdicts tracked in Georgia

Subscribe free and the full Georgia panel opens on this device: the verdict count, total damages, median and largest verdict. Plus one courtroom story every Monday.

Join 1,847 litigation leaders who read it weekly.

During cross-examination, the shopper’s lawyer drew out the defense physician’s expert-witness rates: $2,000 an hour generally and $8,000 for a trial day. In closing, the lawyer asked jurors to consider that daily fee while putting a price on Medders’ pain and suffering. Walmart objected, citing the changes Georgia had made to its trial-argument law in 2025.

The trial judge heard extended argument at the bench. The judge was interpreting new statutory language during closing while an “aggravated” jury waited, the appeals court wrote. The judge allowed the fee comparison because the rate had been admitted in evidence. The shopper’s lawyer then suggested, as the appeals court put it, that the expert’s per diem fee was roughly equivalent to three million dollars a year. Walmart objected again and asked for either a mistrial or an instruction correcting the impression. The judge denied both requests.

The lawyer next proposed a different measure, an hourly rate between $7.25 and $12.15, closer to minimum wage. Walmart objected to that comparison too. The jury returned a $975,000 general verdict for Medders.

The boundary Georgia’s law drew

Stay Informed

Subscribe to Litigation Sentinel

Free weekly intelligence for executives responsible for litigation exposure: the named decision-makers, dollar exposure, operating consequence, and next development.

Join 1,847 litigation leaders who read it weekly.

The appeal, *Wal-Mart Stores East v. Medders*, No. A26A1599, turned on a distinction between evidence heard at trial and the use a lawyer may make of it in closing. Under the earlier version of Georgia’s law, lawyers could argue a monetary value for pain and suffering if the argument conformed to the evidence or a reasonable deduction from it. The version effective April 21, 2025, requires a pain-damages argument to relate rationally to evidence of those damages. It also bars references to objects or values with no rational connection to the facts proved.

The Court of Appeals held that the defense expert’s pay and minimum wage had no rational connection to Medders’ pain. The expert’s rate was evidence in the trial, but that alone did not make it a lawful yardstick for her suffering in closing. The court rejected Medders’ argument that the old and new provisions were essentially the same.

Walmart sought a broader ruling. It argued that assigning pain a value per hour or day was itself impermissible. The appellate court disagreed: lawyers may still make a “unit value” or “per diem” argument, pricing pain by the hour or day. The prohibited move was anchoring that calculation to an unrelated price, such as this expert’s fee or minimum wage.

Why the judgment fell

Walmart won its appeal on the narrower ground. Georgia law requires the trial court to take “remedial measures” when a barred argument is made in the hearing of the jury. Walmart had asked the trial judge for an instruction or a mistrial and received neither. The appeals court held that an uncorrected argument can require reversal when it could have affected the verdict. For defense teams in Georgia trials, Walmart’s record is the template: object each time a closing reaches for an unrelated number, and ask then for a curative instruction or a mistrial.

Medders sought $186,000 in medical bills. After the challenged comparisons, her lawyer asked for approximately $950,000 in noneconomic damages and said an appropriate total award could be $1,136,000. The jury’s $975,000 verdict was a general one, with no separate figure for pain. The P&L: the $975,000 verdict sat $789,000 above the medical bills Medders claimed.

The Atlanta Journal-Constitution described Walmart as the first company to successfully appeal a jury verdict under Georgia’s new law. The paper reported that the trial judge had ordered Walmart to pay just over $926,000. That judgment is now reversed. The ruling addresses how lawyers may argue noneconomic damages in bodily-injury and wrongful-death cases. The signal to watch is the next Georgia closing that prices pain off an unrelated number, and whether that trial judge gives the curative instruction Walmart was denied.

At the new trial, a jury again decides whether the fall worsened Medders’ knee and what that is worth. Her lawyer may still price her pain by the hour or day, but that argument must be rationally related to the evidence of her noneconomic damages, and any renewed objection to an expert’s $8,000 day would arrive with this reversal behind it.

Sources

Want to see where your team stands?

The readiness check has five questions about your reported litigation practices. Use the summary to choose an operating question to explore.

Take the 2-minute readiness check →
Stay Informed

Subscribe to Litigation Sentinel

Free weekly intelligence for executives responsible for litigation exposure: the named decision-makers, dollar exposure, operating consequence, and next development.

Join 1,847 litigation leaders who read it weekly.
Litigation Sentinel
Published by CaseGlide · Subscribe · Request an executive briefing
© 2026 CaseGlide, Inc. All rights reserved.