Litigation SentinelSubscribe free
The weekly brief for F500 legal and claims leaders. Free.
Litigation StrategyCase Watch

Seattle Says Jury Form Put Shooter’s Harm in Its $30,577,908 Judgment

Seattle says a jury held it responsible for harm caused by an unknown shooter after finding its delayed emergency response was a cause of a teenager’s death. Its appeal challenges medical causation, the damages form, and a jury instruction about where the City should have provided aid.

Wesley Todd, CEO, CaseGlideNovember 13, 20265 min read · 986 readers this week

A Washington jury found Seattle’s negligent emergency response a cause of Southern California teenager Antonio Mays Jr.’s death, and the court entered judgment against the City for all $30,577,908. The Seattle Times reported that jurors were shown video of passengers in the vehicle carrying Mays trying to flag down a city ambulance that drove away from them; Seattle argues the verdict form directed jurors to attribute all of the damages, including the unknown shooter’s harm, to the City. In its November 6 opening brief, Seattle asked Division I of the Washington Court of Appeals to set aside the judgment or order a new trial. The brief also attacks a jury instruction on where the City should have provided aid. Its first two arguments ask whether Seattle’s delay caused Mays’ death and whether the verdict form attributed the shooter’s harm to the City.

The response the jury judged

Mays was 16 when he was shot inside Seattle’s Capitol Hill protest zone in June 2020. He had left his family’s home in Southern California with a note to his father saying he wanted to join the civil rights movement, the Seattle Times reported. The newspaper also reported in January that no one had been arrested or charged in his killing.

Nuclear Verdicts dashboard

See the nuclear verdicts tracked in Washington

Subscribe free and the full Washington panel opens on this device: the verdict count, total damages, median and largest verdict. Plus one courtroom story every Monday.

Join 1,847 litigation leaders who read it weekly.

The trial was narrower than the family’s original lawsuit. According to the Seattle Times, King County Superior Court Judge Sean P. O’Donnell removed claims that the City allowed the protest zone to form and persist, leaving the jury to decide whether the City failed in its emergency response. Jurors found the City negligent and found that negligence was a cause of Mays’ death.

Against the ambulance video, Seattle’s brief offers its own account of the timing: City medics reached Mays about 15 minutes after the shooting, it says, only three to four minutes after the family claims care could have begun. The brief also says the vehicle carrying Mays had an armed man riding on its roof and that City medics could not safely enter the protest zone.

Seattle’s survival argument

Seattle’s first route to erasing the judgment is medical causation. Its brief says the family had to prove Mays probably would have survived with timely care, rather than prove that delayed care reduced a chance of survival. The City characterizes testimony from the family’s pediatric critical care expert as giving Mays only a “five to ten percent” chance of surviving even if he had received care within 10 to 15 minutes of being shot. On that reading, Seattle argues, the evidence could support a lost chance, but not a finding that the delay more likely than not caused his death.

Stay Informed

Subscribe to Litigation Sentinel

Free weekly intelligence for executives responsible for litigation exposure: the named decision-makers, dollar exposure, operating consequence, and next development.

Join 1,847 litigation leaders who read it weekly.

The family’s medical case was more than a percentage. The Seattle Times reported that the plaintiffs’ experts testified Mays’ brain wound was not the fatal wound. The City’s brief disputes whether that testimony met the legal standard for the death claim. The jury, asked whether the City’s negligence was a cause of death, answered yes.

**Analysis:** That difference reaches beyond a city government. When someone is injured by a third party and later dies after an alleged delay in aid, a defendant’s exposure can turn on whether the delay is treated as a probable cause of death or as the loss of a smaller chance to survive. Seattle wants the appellate court to make that distinction decisive here, and a ruling for the City could let a defendant answer a death claim with survival odds it attributes to the plaintiff’s own expert.

The question that set the damages

Seattle’s second route concerns the special verdict form, the written questions jurors answered, which the City attached to its brief. As the City describes it, the trial judge instructed jurors to exclude damages caused solely by the shooter. But the form, the City says, asked whether the City was negligent and whether that negligence caused Mays’ death, then asked only for the plaintiffs’ damages, not the amount the City’s negligence caused. Seattle says the form gave jurors no way to show a separate amount for harm caused by the shooter.

That wording is the City’s explanation for how a finding about its emergency response became a judgment for the entire $30,577,908. In its brief, Seattle says the jury awarded $1,209,044 in economic damages to Mays’ estate and $25.9 million in noneconomic damages to his father, an award the City says “illustrates the jury’s confusion.”

The brief points to earlier Washington cases, attaching the verdict form used in one of them, *Rollins v. King County*, and argues that jurors must be asked for the damages the defendant’s negligence caused. At trial, Seattle sought a form that would let jurors separate out damages caused by others, including the shooter. The trial judge used a different form. On April 1, Judge O’Donnell denied the City’s post-trial requests to undo the result, KIRO 7 reported, and the City told KIRO 7, “The City will appeal.”

**P&L:** For a defendant sued over its response to a third party’s crime, the verdict form is a second exposure line, separate from causation. On Seattle’s reading, this form put the full $30,577,908 on the City without asking jurors to state damages caused by the City’s negligence. The decision this week for any defense team in that posture: ask for a damages question that prices the defendant’s share apart from the attacker’s, and make the record when the judge refuses, as Seattle did.

Seattle now asks Division I for judgment in its favor or a new trial, and the Mays family’s response brief is the next filing to watch. This week the award became the newest row in the Washington view of the Nuclear Verdicts dashboard. A new trial on Seattle’s terms would ask jurors the question the City says this form left out: what the City’s delay alone cost the Mays family.

Sources

Want to see where your team stands?

The readiness check has five questions about your reported litigation practices. Use the summary to choose an operating question to explore.

Take the 2-minute readiness check →
Stay Informed

Subscribe to Litigation Sentinel

Free weekly intelligence for executives responsible for litigation exposure: the named decision-makers, dollar exposure, operating consequence, and next development.

Join 1,847 litigation leaders who read it weekly.
Litigation Sentinel
Published by CaseGlide · Subscribe · Request an executive briefing
© 2026 CaseGlide, Inc. All rights reserved.