Oklahoma’s insurance regulator found that 22 of 58 inspected roofs needed replacement or repairs above the deductible after State Farm closed their claims without payment. State Farm disputes the findings and denies wrongdoing; notices to eligible homeowners are due before December 31, 2026.
State Farm’s property insurer reached a $47.86 million regulatory settlement with Oklahoma’s insurance regulator covering residential wind and hail claims with 2021 to 2025 loss dates that were closed without payment. The regulator’s exam order found that 22 of 58 inspected roofs needed replacement or repairs above the deductible; State Farm disputes the findings and denies wrongdoing, and notices to eligible homeowners are due before December 31, 2026. The November 12 settlement agreement directs an independent administrator to review claims homeowners submit. State Farm must put $35 million into an escrow for that review within 30 days of the agreement’s effective date. Any payment will still turn on the individual policy and loss, and a homeowner who accepts one must sign a release.
The agreement is between Oklahoma Insurance Commissioner Glen Mulready and State Farm Fire and Casualty Company, State Farm’s property insurer. It resolves the department’s examination and enforcement matters. It does not turn the regulator’s disputed findings into an admission by State Farm.
The 4 sources behind this story: 3 government records and 1 other source, each linked with what it shows. Free with the weekly Litigation Sentinel brief.
The Oklahoma Insurance Department drew a sample of 181 claims from 4,674 wind and hail roof claims closed without payment between November 2023 and December 2024. Only 58 claimants responded and consented to a roof inspection. The other 123 roofs could not be reviewed because claimants did not respond or chose not to participate.
Hall Engineering inspected roofs for the examiners’ first sample and began on the main one. Its sole professional engineer died in September 2025 before those inspections were largely complete, the exam report says. Another engineering firm produced reports for all 58 roofs ultimately inspected.
Examiners found that 22 of those roofs needed full replacement or repairs costing more than the policy deductible, contrary to State Farm’s decision to close the claims without payment. That is 37.93 percent of the inspected roofs. The commissioner’s order counted the same 22 errors across the full 181-claim sample, yielding an error rate of 12.15 percent. Those are two denominators for the same 22 claims, not two sets of errors.
The report says State Farm was given the benefit of “no errors in 67.96% of the sample selection” because those roofs were not available for review. Even with that treatment, the order found the sample rate exceeded the examination’s 7 percent benchmark. The commissioner adopted the examiners’ finding under Oklahoma’s Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act that in at least 22 instances State Farm did not make a good-faith effort “to promptly, fairly, and equitably settle roofing claims for which liability had become reasonably clear.” State Farm disputes the report’s findings and conclusions.
The order adopted two other findings: three reviewed claims lacked a written denial notice or a retained copy, and State Farm failed to produce requested records on time. State Farm submitted a written rebuttal on October 21 before the commissioner adopted the report on November 10.
Free weekly intelligence for executives responsible for litigation exposure: the named decision-makers, dollar exposure, operating consequence, and next development.
The settlement reaches a different period from the 4,674-claim examination population. Review eligibility covers Oklahoma residential wind and hail claims with loss dates from January 1, 2021, through December 31, 2025, that State Farm closed without payment. Claims already resolved by settlement or final judgment for the same roof loss, and claims withdrawn before a payment decision, are excluded. The agreement puts the limit plainly: “Eligibility for review does not establish entitlement to payment.”
State Farm must send written notices before December 31, 2026. Homeowners then have 180 days from the initial notice to request review. An independent administrator, chosen by the regulator and State Farm, will evaluate each submitted claim under the homeowner’s policy, including causation, coverage and the deductible. Homeowners may submit supporting material when they opt in, but the agreement does not require it at that stage.
The $47.86 million has three parts. State Farm must deposit $35 million into an escrow for the claims review program, though reasonable administration costs may also be paid from it. Another $10 million goes to the Strengthen Oklahoma Homes Revolving Fund, which provides grants to fortify Oklahoma roofs and homes against extreme weather, and $2.86 million covers fines and department expenses. The agreement provides a path to additional funding if approved claims exhaust the escrow. Any money left after approved claims and program costs returns to State Farm. Half must be spent on Oklahoma resilience or residential building programs, or other benefits for Oklahomans that State Farm and the department agree on; the other half goes to national resilience or building standards programs.
A homeowner offered payment must sign a release of all claims against State Farm related to that claim and the review program, including contractual, extracontractual and statutory claims. A homeowner already suing over an eligible claim may enter the program, but must dismiss that claim with prejudice, meaning it cannot be refiled, to receive an approved payment. P&L translation: Of the $47.86 million, $12.86 million (the $10 million fund payment plus $2.86 million in fines and expenses) goes out whatever the review finds. The $35 million escrow pays approved claims and may cover reasonable administration costs. Any remainder returns to State Farm under the spending conditions above. If the escrow runs out and more is needed for eligible claims, State Farm must first replenish it up to the administration costs paid from it; the parties must agree in good faith on any further funding. For defense counsel holding an Oklahoma roof suit over an eligible claim, the plaintiff will receive a notice before December 31 and may opt in, but would have to dismiss the suit to collect an approved payment.
State Farm waived its right to appeal the commissioner’s order as part of the settlement, despite disputing the examination. The department in turn agreed not to open another market conduct examination of State Farm on the same matters for 12 months, provided State Farm stays in material compliance with the order, its corrective action plan and the agreement. The business newspaper Finance & Commerce reported that hundreds of Oklahoma lawsuits alleging unfair claims practices have mounted against State Farm and Allstate, and that the settlement does not settle or divert money toward those homeowner suits.
The next document is the notice State Farm must send before December 31, and the 180-day opt-in window runs from it. The amount approved for payment will show how far the $35 million escrow goes. If it is depleted and the administrator determines more is needed to pay eligible claims, State Farm must first replenish administration costs paid from it; the parties must agree in good faith on any further amount needed to pay approved claims. For 12 months, State Farm must report quarterly how many Oklahoma wind and hail claims it closed without payment and, separately, how many Oklahoma wind and hail claims became the subject of lawsuits against it, to the extent reflected in its ordinary course records.
The readiness check has five questions about your reported litigation practices. Use the summary to choose an operating question to explore.
Take the 2-minute readiness check →Free weekly intelligence for executives responsible for litigation exposure: the named decision-makers, dollar exposure, operating consequence, and next development.