A New York federal judge struck confidentiality designations over nonparty witness Herbert Subin’s Fifth Amendment invocations in Great American’s case. The judge wrote that invoking the right “says nothing whatsoever” about wrongdoing. A later order directed the clerk to unseal the briefs and attachments by agreement.
A federal judge on November 4 struck confidentiality from nonparty witness Herbert Subin’s Fifth Amendment invocations in Great American’s suit alleging a $6 million settlement was procured by fraud. Judge Lewis J. Liman of the Southern District of New York, who on November 6 directed the clerk to unseal the letter briefs and attachments by agreement, had written in the November 4 ruling: “The invocation of the Fifth Amendment says nothing whatsoever about whether a deponent has engaged in any wrongdoing or misconduct.” He also wrote: “Subin has not been charged with any crime, and it is unclear if he ever will be.” For insurers pressing fraud theories in court, the ruling shows a witness’s Fifth Amendment invocations can fall outside a protective order’s shield, carrying the judge’s warning that they say nothing about wrongdoing. A summary judgment filing reached the docket on November 19.
Great American Insurance Co. brought the case. At Subin’s July 24 deposition, when he first invoked the privilege, his counsel said on the record that it was proceeding “against the backdrop of fraud and criminal allegations” in this case and others. Counsel also said Subin’s invocation could not be understood as an admission of guilt or wrongdoing.
The 6 sources behind this story: 5 court records and 1 other source, each linked with what it shows. Free with the weekly Litigation Sentinel brief.
Great American challenged confidentiality designations Subin’s counsel placed on significant portions of the deposition transcript, including counsel’s statement and Subin’s invocations. Subin argued that publicity could taint the pool for a possible future criminal jury. The judge rejected that argument and held that invoking the Fifth Amendment was not personal or intimate information covered by the case’s protective order. Subin sought to protect only “the questions asked of him and the fact that he invoked the Fifth Amendment in response,” the judge wrote. He also found no basis for a separate order shielding the invocations; the court referred to a prior public order discussing related lawsuits.
That ruling has a boundary. Judge Liman denied Great American’s separate request to treat the deposition transcript as a judicial document carrying a presumption of public access. Filing a transcript to contest confidentiality did not, by itself, give it that status.
For anyone litigating fraud through a witness who will not answer, the split is the lesson. Great American won the fight over the designations, but the judge wrote that the invocation “says nothing whatsoever” about whether a deponent engaged in wrongdoing, and the transcript gets no common-law presumption of public access.
Free weekly intelligence for executives responsible for litigation exposure: the named decision-makers, dollar exposure, operating consequence, and next development.
A September order recounts Great American’s allegation that a construction injury suit in New York State Supreme Court, Bronx County, ended in a $6 million settlement obtained by fraud. Great American alleges that Subin Associates recruited people to fake construction injuries, arranged unnecessary medical procedures and paid the recruits through litigation funding services. Those are the insurer’s allegations, not findings, and the court noted in November that Herbert Subin has not been charged with any crime.
The same September order lists related suits, which Litigation Sentinel has covered, brought by Union Mutual Fire Insurance Co., Greater New York Mutual Insurance Co., Roosevelt Road Re Ltd. and Ionian Re LLC. Quoting Great American’s complaint, the order says those suits claim faked accidents on construction sites “representing hundreds of millions of dollars in workers’ compensation payments and liability insurance settlements.” That figure is the complaint’s characterization of other suits’ claims.
The same judge has protected the right to stay silent. In September he upheld another nonparty witness’s Fifth Amendment invocation, finding the witness’s fear of prosecution reasonable. Judge Liman’s later October order denied a Great American request for documents from a related nonparty company because the insurer brought it after fact discovery closed and had not shown good cause for the delay.
Related: New York verdicts.
P&L translation: the dollar figure at stake is the $6 million settlement Great American alleges was procured by fraud. The November 4 ruling moves no money; it changes what can be disclosed about a witness’s deposition while that allegation is tested. A claims team pressing a fraud theory now has an order to cite on that point. The scoreboard so far: Great American won on the confidentiality designations, lost its bid to make the transcript a judicial document, lost its bid to compel another witness’s answers and lost a late document request. The court docket records a summary judgment filing on November 19, the next thread in the $6 million fight.
The readiness check has five questions about your reported litigation practices. Use the summary to choose an operating question to explore.
Take the 2-minute readiness check →Free weekly intelligence for executives responsible for litigation exposure: the named decision-makers, dollar exposure, operating consequence, and next development.